The Trouble With Orange Juice – Part II

October 29th, 2010 by Colonel Tiki
This is the first in a series of articles on Citrus.

In Part I, I discussed how squeezing fresh juice from common oranges is a poor choice for orange juice, and suggested an easy (though seasonal) solution in a few good varietals suited for juice. We all need to be aware of the method of production of the processed orange juice product.

The Queasy Fix: Processed Orange Juice

orange_frankTo be candid, processed orange juice is Frankenstein’s monster. It doesn’t really matter if it is from concentrate (FCOJ) or not from concentrate (NFC).  The juice may have been freshly squeezed at one time, but the journey it takes to your jigger renders it far from “fresh squeezed.”

In her book, Squeezed: What You Don’t Know About Orange JuiceAlissa Hamilton1, a recent Food and Society Fellow with the Institute of Agriculture and Trade Policy, describes the NFC process. Here’s the scoop:

Freshly squeezed juice is first centrifuged to remove the oils.2 Next, after pasteurization, the most production popular method de-oxygenates the juice for protection against spoilage. This is because all the excess Valencias (in Florida and Brazil) are processed and held in huge aseptic tanks for storage and use when not in season.

This volume keeps the NFC OJ available year-round. Since removing the oxygen destroys almost all organic-compound flavors in the juice, producers purchase flavor packs from fragrance and flavor companies. The product is re-flavored and shipped to you.

From concentrate orange juice doesn’t get de-oxygenated, but it does get superheated to remove excess water. This process destroys flavors so producers purchase flavor packs from fragrance and flavor companies.3 Sound familiar? The concentrate is frozen and stored to reconstitute and bottle, or sold directly to you in the add 3 cans of cold water containers we all grew up with.

So should you avoid processed orange juice products? It’s up to you. Personally, I do use it in certain circumstances. It all comes down to the taste: Some producers have a relatively decent flavor pack combination that mimics fresh Valencias enough to be a substitute. I call on Frankenstein when all I can find is out-of season or boring common oranges, or if you cannot find a local fresh4 juice in jugs at your Whole Joes, or if you only have convenience stores or mega-grocery-marts near you and you have an OJ emergency.5

Coming in the third and final part, I’ll go into fresh juice products and my own personal recommendation for the orange juice conundrum.

Edit: Please consider purchasing Squeezed:


  1. Who is a very nice person to email []
  2. which are sold to the same market where fragrance and flavor companies shop for raw natural ingredients []
  3. []
  4. where fresh means sell-by-date ranges of 3 days or so []
  5. it happens more that I’d like to admit []

8 Responses to “The Trouble With Orange Juice – Part II”

  1. Trader Tiki says:

    Orange I glad you wrote this?

    That’s an interesting debate, Concentrate or not from…. now what was that book that discussed that? I fear my ability to google has left my body. Please provide an amazon link, affiliated, for sure.

  2. Great info thanks Craig!

  3. Colonel Tiki says:

    Good idea, the amazon link is above.

  4. JokeIII says:

    A good “something” to have up our collective sleeve is to make our own flavor pack to boost the taste of whatever juice we end up buying. Pretty simple: Strip the zest — no pith, please — off EVERY ORANGE you get. Stick it in a mason jar and cover with, say, vodka. As the jar gets crowded with peel (and the liquid turns orange), strain and re-jar and re-stuff with peel. You will be amazed, astonished and floored at the boost this gives your commercial OJ. (I use ¼t. per oz. of OJ, but you do whatever.)


  5. Rick says:

    You make a great point that the taste of the product is often more important than its origin, or process. What’s your favorite brand of OJ?

  6. Bradford says:

    Hey there!

    I really want to see the final part — tried squeezing Navels myself, they were AWFUL. Good call on that.

    Excited to hear your recommendations 😀

  7. Colonel Tiki says:

    Bradford, you won’t have to wait too long. The final part of the OJ series publishes on Monday, and will include my own personal priority go-to list for OJ sourcing. Next up in the series will be Grapefruit. Beautiful, delicious, complex grapefruit: my favorite of the Citrus family.

  8. Colonel Tiki says:

    Rick, I’ll get to that in Part III 🙂

Leave a Reply